When will Mississippi learn?
A state whose education system consistently ranks as one of the worst in the country can’t get something as simple as a school rating system right.
The State Board of Education recently voted in favor of a dramatic change to the school rating system, one that sets in stone the number of schools and school districts that can be rated in each of the A through F categories in a given year.
With this measure exactly 10 percent of schools will be allowed an A rating, regardless of how well (or how poorly) schools perform as a whole and exactly 14 percent will be graded as an F.
This change is extremely different from the current system, which sets a minimum score that a school or school district must achieve to earn a given rating, which makes sense.
Take this into a classroom scenario with the top 10 percent of students in a class can get an A, regardless of their effort or lack of effort.
According to the proposed policy, even if all districts attained the highest possible test scores, academic growth, and graduation rates, 14 percent of them would still be assigned an F.
Likewise, if all districts sank to the lowest possible performance, 10 percent of them would still get an A.
This "Hunger Games" approach to rating schools discourages collaboration among school districts making it impossible for a district to move up a level without another one falling.
We should be encouraging collaboration amongst educators in order for Mississippi to improve. This one-for-all approach will not work and the only people paying the consequences are the students.
Joseph Brown is the editor and publisher of The Star-Herald. He can be reached at jbrown@starherald.net