Lo and behold, Mississippi has elected an African American Democratic
U.S. Senator. Who would have believed it?
Mississippi has not elected a Democrat to the U.S. Senate since John Stennis in 1982. That’s 44 years. Mississippi last elected a Black U.S. Senator when Blanche Bruce was elected as a Republican in 1874.
Scott Colom is the first Black Democrat
U.S. Senator in history, winning with 49.36 percent of the vote.
Mississippi, along with 49 other states, requires a plurality to win the U.S. Senate race. Georgia is the only state that requires a runoff.
Ironically, Mississippi requires a majority for U.S. Senate special elections, which occur when a senator dies or resigns, but not for U.S. Senate regular elections.
Colom’s victory is all the more surprising given that Black independent candidate Ty Pinkins siphoned off 2.1 percent of the vote. One would think Pinkins, with his center left platform, would hurt Colom more than the incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith.
Hyde-Smith had previously defeated former U.S. Agriculture Secretary Mike Espy by 7.2 points in 2018 and 10 points in 2020. Espy was no slouch.
The big difference in this election was the decrease in Republican votes. In Hyde-Smith’s 2020 race against Espy, she got 709,511 votes. This time she only got 470,179 votes. That’s a whopping 33.7 percent decline in votes, a 239,332 decrease in votes.
But the expected mid-term voter turnout drop off was far less for Colom than Hyde-Smith.
Colom had only 102,571 fewer votes than Espy did in 2020, less than half the decline of the Republican turnout. Compared to the 2018 Espy v. Hyde-Smith race, which was also a mid-term election, turnout in 2026 was 972,744 versus 907,588 in 2018.
Turnout is related to money and Colom brought in the big bucks, according to ChatGPT. Adjusted for inflation, Colom and his supporters spent $18.9 million compared to Espy’s $10.8 million. Meanwhile, Hyde-Smith spent $6.1 million in 2026, only a third of what Colom spent.
Tracking all the campaign expenditures is tricky, given that there are so many outside groups that may run independent ads supporting or attacking a candidate. But it’s safe to say, Colom’s camp had substantially more money than Hyde-Smith’s.
This aligns with national data, which indicates Democrats spent $3.1 billion compared to $2.3 billion for the Republicans.
The Republican mid-term losses were the third biggest loss over the last nine mid-term elections. But the losses in 2010, when Obama was President, and 1994, when Clinton was President, were bigger losses.
Given that 36 percent of registered Mississippi voters are African-American, and that over 95 percent of them are Democrats, it should not be a huge surprise that Colom won.
Meanwhile, 61 percent of Mississippi registered voters are white and 80 percent of them vote Republican.
Given those numbers, the Republicans go into any statewide race with an expected 48.8 percent of the vote and the Democrats go in with an expected 34.2 percent.
So for the Democrats to win statewide, there needs to be a 7.4 point swing from normal voting patterns. Overall nationally, the swing was 8.35 points — barely enough to elect a Democrat senator in Mississippi. And that’s exactly what happened, despite the Ty Pinkins voter probably hurting Colom.
The Mississippi Republican party, which has held a monopoly on the U.S. Senate seats, is not impervious to national political swings.
Those are the numbers, but personalities play a big role. Hyde-Smith had been developing a reputation, deserved or not, of being stand-offish, hands-off, and not particularly charismatic. She unapologetically hitched her wagon to the Trump star, far more than her colleague Roger Wicker. When Trump’s support collapsed, so did hers
Meanwhile, Colom was perceived as friendly, charismatic and kinda warm and fuzzy. Wisely, he avoided all the hot button Democratic cultural issues that so rile Mississippi conservatives. He laser focused on inflation, health care and the cost of living — bread and butter issues that rallied Mississippi’s large middle class.
It is amazing to me that Trump, having been re-elected because of Democrat-induced inflation, proceeded to then use tariffs and a war to reignite the same inflation that swept him back into power. Go figure.
Make no mistake, getting elected a U.S. Senator requires an immensely complex skill set. Hyde-Smith is no dummy and neither is Scott Colom. But Colom brought a greater skill set to bear on this election than Hyde-Smith. That’s why he won. Everyone’s seen the brilliant “choose another protein” viral video. That doesn’t happen in a vacuum. Chance does sometimes favor the bold.
Personally, I think competition is always good. I have never liked the fact that Mississippi tends to be a one-party state. Electing a Black Democrat helps our image nationally and heals racial wounds.
The most fascinating sub plot is that Colom was on his way to becoming a federal district judge in north Mississippi. Wicker gave Colom a thumbs up, but Hyde-Smith blackballed him, a partisan maneuver which solidified her Trump base.
As the Little Feat song goes, “The people you misuse on your way up, you might meet up, on your way back down.” Or as they say, Karma’s a bitch.