Once again, Mr. Chip Williams has written about how awful he thinks "socialized medicine", universal healthcare, and single payer systems are. After reading his most recent article, I chuckled to myself and then I had to scratch my head and wonder why he continues to write about his opinion that clearly is not substantiated in facts. Self- deception, perhaps? It sounds like he chooses to believe something and then looks for articles to support his view. I, on the other hand, peruse many trusted sites to see if the same information appears on them and if it does, I trust that information. It's the same reason I do NOT watch FOX News. I don't think they can be trusted. Perhaps they are the fundamental reason for Mr. Williams' opinion. If so, I would encourage Mr. Williams to add additional news sources to his information diet.
So, now, I present my case (again). Respectfully speaking, judging from his photo, Mr. Williams appears to be a gentleman who has been on Medicare for several years now. And what is amusing is that Medicare is considered a "single payer" system. So, I would ask Mr. Williams, if he thinks we should eliminate Medicare or worse, privatize it? I'm just guessing, but I'm thinking his answer would be "no." I would also ask the gentleman if he thinks we should eliminate the VA medical system for veterans, because it is America's version of "socialized" medicine. And again, I'm guessing but I think our veterans would say "absolutely not."
Medicare is not considered socialized medicine because it is a single-payer program where the government pays for medical services, but the healthcare providers and facilities are mostly privately operated. Which I believe, is what Mr. Williams is unintentionally advocating for. And it is NOT free, as he implied. People pay in FICA taxes with every paycheck they earn throughout their years of work which in turn, pays for Medicare when they turn 65. And as he should know by now, Medicare has a monthly premium and yearly deductible just like private insurance. Only, those premiums and deductibles are significantly lower than that of private insurance because: a) of the size of the group, the government can negotiate much lower costs for parts A and B, b) because it is stteamlined, the administrative costs are also significantly lower, and last but not least, c) THE GOVERNMENT DOES NOT MAKE A PROFIT OFF OF THOSE INSURED AS DOES PRIVATE INSURANCE. In essence, it appears that Mr. Williams is trying to say something that just does not add up.
As for the economic statistics for our nation, an AI search revealed the following:
"A single-payer universal health care system could cover every American, save more than 100,000 lives a year, and still cost $1 trillion less than the system it would replace, according to a new preprint study led by researchers at the Yale School of Public Health.
For the study, which has not yet been peer reviewed, the researchers modeled what would happen if the United States adopted a national public insurance program like the one proposed in the Medicare for All Act. Using 2024 spending, insurance coverage, and mortality data, they estimate that the universal coverage would reduce annual health expenditures by $1.04 trillion, or nearly 20% — even after accounting for the additional care that uninsured and underinsured people would receive."
This clearly debunks Mr. Williams' argument that our privatized health insurance is the best. IT CLEARLY IS NOT. The AI search goes on to say:
"The U.S., on average, has the poorest health outcomes of any high-income country, and among the poorest of the high- and middle-income nations belonging to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). Lack of universal coverage, weak primary care infrastructure, high out-of-pocket costs, and a complex insurance system contribute to and exacerbate the nation’s uniquely poor performance relative to its peers."
The sites I retrieved this data from: www.commonwealthfund and the article is titled: "U.S. Healthcare From a Global Perspective, 2026” and https://ysph.yale.edu/news-article/universal-health-coverage-could-save…
In closing, such a system is also morally superior to the broken healthcare system we currently have.
Camille Wright is a Northsider.